Crystal Lake Waterfront for Sale in Plymouth, Wisconsin
Crystal Lake Waterfront Listings in Plymouth, Wisconsin
Explore 4 Crystal Lake lakefront listings in Plymouth, Wisconsin, including lakefront homes, cabins, cottages, vacant lots, and commercial properties for sale Prices range from $2,000,000 to $4,479,000.
Showing 1 - 4 of 4
Crystal Lake Waterfront Real Estate Market — Plymouth, Wisconsin
Market data calculated 5/21/2026
4
Total Listings
Sheboygan County: 576
$2,869,750
Average Price
Sheboygan County: $377,315
$2,500,000
Median Price
Sheboygan County: $247,000
$723
Price / Sq Ft
Sheboygan County: $235
37 days
Days on Market
Sheboygan County: 149 days
Current Market Condition
Seller's Market (High Demand)
Based on an average of 37 days on market.
See how your property compares to these regional averages.
Get Your Free Home Value ReportGet a professional analysis of your home's worth based on current Plymouth, Wisconsin trends.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many homes are for sale on Crystal Lake Waterfront in Plymouth, Wisconsin?
There are currently 4 properties listed for sale on Crystal Lake Waterfront in Plymouth, Wisconsin.
What is the median home price on Crystal Lake Waterfront in Plymouth, Wisconsin?
The median listing price on Crystal Lake Waterfront in Plymouth, Wisconsin is $2,500,000.
What is the average home price on Crystal Lake Waterfront in Plymouth, Wisconsin?
The average listing price on Crystal Lake Waterfront in Plymouth, Wisconsin is $2,869,750.
How long do homes stay on the market on Crystal Lake Waterfront in Plymouth, Wisconsin?
Properties on Crystal Lake Waterfront in Plymouth, Wisconsin stay on the market for an average of 37 days before selling.
What types of properties are available on Crystal Lake Waterfront in Plymouth, Wisconsin?
Properties currently listed on Crystal Lake Waterfront in Plymouth, Wisconsin include: Single-Family Homes.
What is the average price per square foot for homes on Crystal Lake Waterfront in Plymouth, Wisconsin?
The average price per square foot for homes listed on Crystal Lake Waterfront in Plymouth, Wisconsin is $723.
What is the price range for homes for sale on Crystal Lake Waterfront in Plymouth, Wisconsin?
Homes for sale on Crystal Lake Waterfront in Plymouth, Wisconsin are currently priced from $2,000,000 to $4,479,000.
How do home prices in Crystal Lake Waterfront in Plymouth, Wisconsin compare to Sheboygan County?
The average listing price on Crystal Lake Waterfront in Plymouth, Wisconsin is $2,869,750, compared to $377,315 for all of Sheboygan County — above the county average.
Is Crystal Lake Waterfront in Plymouth, Wisconsin a buyer's or seller's market?
Based on current days on market (37 days on average), Crystal Lake Waterfront in Plymouth, Wisconsin is considered a Seller's Market (High Demand). Homes are selling quickly, indicating higher demand relative to supply.