Gibraltar Area School District Listings in Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Explore 7 active listings in the Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, including single-family homes, condos, lots, vacant land, multi-family and commercial properties for sale Prices range from $84,900 to $549,900.

7 listings in Sister Bay, Wisconsin Refine Search Map View
Showing 1 - 7 of 7

Gibraltar Area School District Real Estate Market — Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Market data calculated 4/17/2026
7 Total Listings Door County: 144
$249,214 Average Price Door County: $571,010
$199,900 Median Price Door County: $299,900
$145 Price / Sq Ft Door County: $350
138 days Days on Market Door County: 173 days
Current Market Condition Balanced Market

Based on an average of 137 days on market.

See how your property compares to these regional averages.

Get Your Free Home Value Report

Get a professional analysis of your home's worth based on current Sister Bay, Wisconsin trends.

About Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Sister Bay is one of the most beloved villages on the Door Peninsula, known for its picturesque waterfront on Green Bay, lively downtown with local shops and restaurants, and the famous Al Johnson's Swedish Restaurant with goats on its grass roof. The village sits in the heart of northern Door County and serves as a hub for tourism and year-round community life. Real estate in Sister Bay includes waterfront cottages and homes along Green Bay, historic in-village properties, and newer residential development, attracting buyers seeking a vibrant resort-town lifestyle on the Door Peninsula.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many homes are for sale in Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin?
There are currently 7 properties listed for sale in Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin.
What is the median home price in Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin?
The median listing price in Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin is $199,900.
What is the average home price in Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin?
The average listing price in Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin is $249,214.
How long do homes stay on the market in Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin?
Properties in Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin stay on the market for an average of 137 days before selling.
What types of properties are available in Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin?
Properties currently listed in Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin include: Vacant Land / Lots, Commercial Properties.
What is the average price per square foot for homes in Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin?
The average price per square foot for homes listed in Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin is $145.
What is the price range for homes for sale in Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin?
Homes for sale in Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin are currently priced from $84,900 to $549,900.
How do home prices in Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin compare to Door County?
The average listing price in Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin is $249,214, compared to $571,010 for all of Door County — below the county average.
Is Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin a buyer's or seller's market?
Based on current days on market (137 days on average), Gibraltar Area School District in Sister Bay, Wisconsin is considered a Balanced Market. Supply and demand are roughly equal, giving both buyers and sellers fair negotiating conditions.