$575,000

3 Beds 2 Baths 1,684 Sqft

5231 N Bay Ridge Avenue, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217

Property Type: Single-Family
Building Type: 2 Story
Time on Market: 19 days
Price per Sqft: $341
Garage: 2 Car
Total Taxes: $4,328
Est. Age: 21+ Years

Description

Charm meets modern convenience in this beautifully refreshed Whitefish Bay Cape Cod! From the moment you step inside, you will be greeted by a sun-drenched living room featuring an oversized picture window that fills the home with warm, natural light. Hardwood floors glide effortlessly into the formal dining room, setting the perfect stage for hosting dinner parties or casual family weeknights. Beyond the dining space, a massive rear family room anchored by built-in shelving offers the ultimate footprint for relaxation, movie nights, or a dedicated play area.

Property Details

Interior

Appliances:
  • Dryer, Oven, Range, Refrigerator, Washer
Basement:
  • Full
Baths:
  • Full Baths: 2
  • Bath Descriptions: Master Bedroom Bath
Heating/Cooling:
  • Forced Air
Heat Fuel:
  • Natural Gas
Sqft:
  • Total Sqft: 1,684
  • Lot Sqft Source: Other - See Remarks
  • Estimated Sqft Range: 1501-1750

Rooms

Room Basement Level Lower Level Main Level Upper Level
Master Bedroom 16x15
Bedroom 2 11x12
Dining Room 9x13
Family Room 24x14
Kitchen 10x13
Living Room 13x16

Exterior

Acreage:
  • Range: 0.0 to .499
  • Source: Assessor/Public Record
Exterior:
  • Vinyl
Garage:
  • Details: Opener Included, Detached, 2 Car
  • Spaces: 2.0
Style:
  • Cape Cod
Water:
  • Waterfront: N
Water/Waste:
  • Municipal Sewer, Municipal Water

Misc.

New Construction:
  • N
Postal:
  • Code: 53217
Street:
  • Direction Prefix: N
  • Name: Bay Ridge AVENUE
  • Suffix: AVENUE
Tax Year:
  • 2025
Zoning:
  • res

Map

Monthly Payment Calculator

$
Enter the listed price of the home.
$
Enter the down payment amount in dollars.
%
Enter the down payment percentage.
%
Enter the annual interest rate for the mortgage.
Est.
0.00
/month
Principal & Interest
$
Property Taxes
$
Enter the monthly property taxes.
Home Insurance
$
Enter the monthly home insurance cost.
Mortgage Insurance
$
Enter the monthly mortgage insurance cost.
HOA Fees
$
Enter the monthly HOA fees.
Utilities
$
Enter the monthly utilities cost.

Schools and Neighborhood

Middle School:
  • Whitefish Bay
High School:
  • Whitefish Bay
School District:
  • Whitefish Bay
Postal City:
  • Whitefish Bay
Municipality:
  • Name: WHITEFISH BAY
  • Type: Village
County:
  • MILWAUKEE

Market Comparison

How this property compares to local market averages — calculated 8/5/2026

This Property
Whitefish Bay Single Family Home Avg
Milwaukee County Single Family Home Avg
List Price
$575,000
$755,151
$338,760
Median Price
$565,000
$279,900
Price / Sq Ft
$341
$337
$192
Days on Market
19 days
25 days
37 days
Total Listings
29
1,293

Listing Information

  • Time on Market: 19 days
  • Place Perfect Last Updated: 2026-07-17 02:21:12
  • MLS Number: 1971462
  • Subsystem Locale: WIREX_METRO
  • Listing Office: Real Broker Milwaukee
  • Listing Agent: Patrick Simonis
WIREX Logo

This information is provided by WIREX via the REALTORS Association of Northeast Wisconsin multiple listing service and is exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

© 2026 WIREX-Wisconsin Real Estate Exchange – All Rights Reserved