$399,900

5 Beds 3 Baths 2,488 Sqft

226 Forest Avenue, Plymouth, WI 53073

Property Type: Single-Family
Building Type: 2 Story
Time on Market: 12 hours
Price per Sqft: $161
Garage: 2 Car
Total Taxes: $5,172
Est. Age: 21+ Years

Description

CHARMING VICTORIAN HOME WITH TIMELESS CHARACTER! Step into the history & charm of this beautiful two-story home, built in 1887 & filled with the craftsmanship & architectural details that make historic homes so special. Situated on an oversized .38+/-acre lot, this property offers a rare combination of character, space and privacy! Inside, you'll find hardwood flooring throughout, gorgeous original woodwork, crown molding, leaded glass doors, & tall ceilings. Upper primary suite with dressing area and full bath. Outside, enjoy the private, fenced-in yard surrounded by mature trees! A welcoming front porch adds to the home's classic curb appeal, while the deck provides additional outdoor living space. For added convenience & versatility, the property features 2 detached 1-Car garages!

Property Details

Interior

Appliances:
  • Dishwasher, Dryer, Microwave, Range/Oven, Refrigerator, Washer
Basement:
  • Full, Stone
Baths:
  • Full Baths: 2
  • Half Baths: 1
Heating/Cooling:
  • Radiant
Heat Fuel:
  • Natural Gas
Interior Features:
  • Wood Floors
Sqft:
  • Total Sqft: 2,488
  • Lot Sqft Source: Assessor/Public Record
  • Estimated Sqft Range: 2001-2500

Rooms

Room Basement Level Lower Level Main Level Upper Level
Master Bedroom 13x11
Bedroom 2 13x11
Bedroom 3 12x11
Bedroom 4 12x10
Bedroom 5 13x8
Dining Room 15x12
Family Room 19x15
Kitchen 13x10
Living Room 22x14
Other 13x10

Exterior

Acreage:
  • Range: 0.0 to .499
  • Source: Assessor/Public Record
Exterior:
  • Aluminum/Steel
Exterior Features:
  • Deck, Fenced Yard, Patio
Garage:
  • Details: Detached, 2 Car, 1 Car, Additional Garage(s), 2 Car
  • Spaces: 2.0
Lot:
  • Description: Sidewalks
Style:
  • Cape Cod
Water:
  • Waterfront: N
Water/Waste:
  • Municipal Water, Municipal Sewer

Misc.

New Construction:
  • N
Postal:
  • Code: 53073
Street:
  • Name: FOREST AVENUE
  • Suffix: AVENUE
Zoning:
  • Residential

Map

Listing Agent-Provided Directions:
  • Highway 23 to S on Milwaukee Street, E on Forest Ave, Property is on your left.

Monthly Payment Calculator

$
$
%
%
Est.
0.00
/month
Principal & Interest
$
Property Taxes
$
Home Insurance
$
Mortgage Insurance
$
HOA Fees
$
Utilities
$

Schools and Neighborhood

School District:
  • Plymouth
Postal City:
  • Plymouth
Municipality:
  • Name: PLYMOUTH
  • Type: City
County:
  • SHEBOYGAN

Market Comparison

How this property compares to local market averages — calculated 9/10/2026

This Property
Plymouth Single Family Home Avg
Sheboygan County Single Family Home Avg
List Price
$399,900
$745,497
$560,104
Median Price
—
$518,900
$367,600
Price / Sq Ft
$161
$269
$244
Days on Market
12 hours
53 days
51 days
Total Listings
—
34
254

Listing Information

  • Time on Market: 12 hours
  • Place Perfect Last Updated: 2026-09-09 14:50:01
  • MLS Number: 50332321
  • Subsystem Locale: WIREX_RANW
  • Listing Office: Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
  • Listing Agent: Tiffany Holtz

Homes with 5 bedrooms

Explore nearby homes with 5 bedrooms

Plymouth School District Homes

Explore Plymouth school district homes in Plymouth, Wisconsin

WIREX Logo

This information is provided by WIREX via the REALTORS Association of Northeast Wisconsin multiple listing service and is exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

© 2026 WIREX-Wisconsin Real Estate Exchange – All Rights Reserved