$389,900

2 Beds 3 Baths 2,362 Sqft

123 S Ithaca Avenue, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235

Property Type: Single-Family
Building Type: 1 Story
Time on Market: 4 days
Price per Sqft: $165
Garage: 2 Car
Total Taxes: $4,385
Est. Age: 21+ Years

Description

First time on the market! This meticulously maintained 2-bedroom, 2.5-bath ranch, 2 FP with a walkout basement offers a rare opportunity to own a cherished home with deep ties to Sturgeon Bay's maritime history. Connected to the legacy of Marine Travelift and the city's renowned shipbuilding heritage, this one-owner home has been lovingly cared for and updated over the years. Quality craftsmanship, inviting living spaces, and timeless character blend seamlessly with modern comfort. More than just a home, it represents an important chapter in the community's history while offering the perfect place to create lasting memories for generations to come.

Property Details

Interior

Appliances:
  • Cooktop, Dishwasher, Dryer, Microwave, Oven, Refrigerator
Basement:
  • Block, Full, Walk Out/Outer Door
Baths:
  • Full Baths: 2
  • Half Baths: 1
  • Bath Descriptions: Master Bedroom Bath: Walk-In Shower,Master Bedroom Bath
Heating/Cooling:
  • Central Air
Heat Fuel:
  • Natural Gas
Interior Features:
  • Water Softener
Sqft:
  • Total Sqft: 2,362
  • Lot Sqft Source: Appraisal
  • Estimated Sqft Range: 2001-2500

Rooms

Room Basement Level Lower Level Main Level Upper Level
Master Bedroom 16x13
Bedroom 2 12x11
Dining Room 11x9
Kitchen 10x11
Living Room 20x13
Other Room 10x6

Exterior

Acreage:
  • Range: 0.0 to .499
  • Source: Assessor/Public Record
Exterior:
  • Aluminum, Aluminum/Steel
Garage:
  • Details: Opener Included, Attached, 2 Car
  • Spaces: 2.0
Style:
  • Ranch
Water:
  • Waterfront: N
Water/Waste:
  • Municipal Sewer, Municipal Water

Misc.

New Construction:
  • N
Postal:
  • Code: 54235
Street:
  • Direction Prefix: S
  • Name: Ithaca AVENUE
  • Suffix: AVENUE
Tax Year:
  • 2025
Zoning:
  • Residential

Map

Listing Agent-Provided Directions:
  • From 42/57 to Green Bay Rd turn W onto W Pine Street to right or N on S Ithaca Ave.

Monthly Payment Calculator

$
Enter the listed price of the home.
$
Enter the down payment amount in dollars.
%
Enter the down payment percentage.
%
Enter the annual interest rate for the mortgage.
Est.
0.00
/month
Principal & Interest
$
Property Taxes
$
Enter the monthly property taxes.
Home Insurance
$
Enter the monthly home insurance cost.
Mortgage Insurance
$
Enter the monthly mortgage insurance cost.
HOA Fees
$
Enter the monthly HOA fees.
Utilities
$
Enter the monthly utilities cost.

Schools and Neighborhood

Middle School:
  • Walker
High School:
  • Sturgeon Bay
School District:
  • Sturgeon Bay
Postal City:
  • Sturgeon Bay
Municipality:
  • Name: STURGEON BAY
  • Type: City
County:
  • DOOR

Market Comparison

How this property compares to local market averages — calculated 8/5/2026

This Property
Sturgeon Bay Single Family Home Avg
Door County Single Family Home Avg
List Price
$389,900
$944,637
$951,743
Median Price
$512,000
$619,900
Price / Sq Ft
$165
$397
$423
Days on Market
4 days
66 days
69 days
Total Listings
40
69

Listing Information

  • Time on Market: 4 days
  • Place Perfect Last Updated: 2026-08-01 09:33:13
  • MLS Number: 1974178
  • Subsystem Locale: WIREX_METRO
  • Listing Office: Response Realtors
  • Listing Agent: Christle Novak
WIREX Logo

This information is provided by WIREX via the REALTORS Association of Northeast Wisconsin multiple listing service and is exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

© 2026 WIREX-Wisconsin Real Estate Exchange – All Rights Reserved